Justin Trudeau’s leadership began with promise but ended in economic struggles, scandals, and division, leading to his resignation and Canada’s political shift.

Top of Form

When Justin Trudeau became Canada’s Prime Minister in 2015, he brought with him a wave of optimism, progressive ideals, and a vision of inclusivity. His leadership revitalized the Liberal Party, catapulting it from third place in Parliament to a majority government. Trudeau’s campaign promises—climate action, gender equality, and Indigenous reconciliation—offered a stark contrast to the decade-long Conservative governance under Stephen Harper.

However, nearly a decade later, Trudeau’s political dominance has eroded. A combination of economic struggles, policy failures, and controversies weakened his standing with the public, leading to his eventual resignation on January 6, 2025. His departure marks the end of an era that began with high hopes but concluded with disappointment and division.

The Economic Decline: A Major Catalyst for Trudeau’s Downfall

One of the primary reasons behind Trudeau’s diminishing popularity was his government’s failure to address growing economic concerns. Canadians have grappled with rising costs of living, housing affordability crises, and sluggish economic growth.

Housing Affordability Crisis

Under Trudeau, home prices soared to unprecedented levels, particularly in cities like Toronto and Vancouver. Despite implementing the First-Time Home Buyer Incentive, his government failed to address systemic issues such as restrictive zoning laws, supply shortages, and the role of foreign investors. Housing prices outpaced income growth, leaving many Canadians—especially younger generations—struggling to afford homeownership.

Rising Inflation and Sluggish Growth

Inflation hit 6.8% in 2022, fueled by global supply chain disruptions and increased government spending during the COVID-19 pandemic. Although inflation eventually declined, economic uncertainty persisted. GDP growth averaged just 0.3% per year, making it one of the weakest periods in recent Canadian history. Critics argued that Trudeau’s economic policies—such as high government spending and taxation—contributed to economic stagnation.

Ballooning Deficit and Fiscal Mismanagement

The federal deficit reached $61.9 billion in 2023–2024, far exceeding the government’s projected target of $40.1 billion. Concerns about fiscal responsibility intensified, with many questioning whether the Liberal government was spending beyond its means. Trudeau’s fiscal policies alienated both conservative-leaning voters who opposed deficit spending and progressives who felt the funds were misallocated.

Freeland’s Resignation: The Final Blow

In December 2024, Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland resigned, citing disagreements over economic policies and Canada’s response to U.S. President Donald Trump’s proposed 25% tariff on Canadian imports. Freeland’s departure signaled deep divisions within the Liberal Party and raised doubts about Trudeau’s leadership. It also exacerbated fears of economic instability, reinforcing public frustration with the government’s handling of financial matters.

Scandals and Controversies: Eroding Public Trust

Beyond economic woes, Trudeau’s tenure was marred by several high-profile scandals and policy reversals that chipped away at his credibility.

The SNC-Lavalin Scandal

In 2019, Trudeau faced serious ethical concerns after reports emerged that his office had pressured then-Attorney General Jody Wilson-Raybould to intervene in the corruption case against SNC-Lavalin, a major Canadian engineering firm. The federal ethics commissioner ruled that Trudeau violated conflict of interest laws, fueling perceptions of political interference. The scandal damaged his image as a champion of transparency and fairness.

The Trans Mountain Pipeline Controversy

Trudeau’s approval of the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion contradicted his climate commitments and Indigenous reconciliation efforts. Environmentalists and Indigenous groups opposed the project, accusing the government of prioritizing economic interests over environmental protection. The move alienated many progressive voters who had supported Trudeau for his strong climate action promises.

The Freedom Convoy and Emergency Powers

The Freedom Convoy protests of early 2022 marked another divisive moment in Trudeau’s leadership. Initially a protest against vaccine mandates for cross-border truckers, the demonstrations evolved into a broader opposition movement against COVID-19 restrictions. Protesters blocked downtown Ottawa and key trade routes like the Ambassador Bridge, leading Trudeau to invoke the Emergencies Act—a move seen by some as necessary for restoring order and by others as excessive government overreach. The crackdown on protesters and freezing of financial accounts deepened political polarization.

Internal Party Divisions and Trudeau’s Resignation

As Trudeau’s approval ratings plummeted, internal dissent within the Liberal Party grew louder. Several Members of Parliament (MPs) openly questioned his leadership, warning that the party risked electoral defeat if he remained in power.

Ontario MP Chad Collins publicly stated that the Liberal caucus was “not united” behind Trudeau, underscoring the growing dissatisfaction. The party’s declining poll numbers further fueled calls for change. By early 2025, Trudeau faced mounting pressure from within his own ranks, ultimately leading to his decision to step down. In his resignation speech, he admitted that internal battles had become a distraction, declaring that Canada deserved a “real choice” in the next election.

What’s Next for Canada?

Trudeau’s departure leaves the Liberal Party at a crossroads. The party must choose a new leader who can restore public confidence and counter the growing influence of the Conservative Party, led by Pierre Poilievre.

Potential Successors: Freeland vs. Carney

Two frontrunners have emerged in the race to succeed Trudeau:

• Chrystia Freeland: As a former Finance Minister and Deputy Prime Minister, Freeland has strong political experience and a solid party base. However, her close ties to Trudeau may make it difficult for her to distance herself from his legacy.
• Mark Carney: The former Bank of England Governor offers a fresh perspective with deep economic expertise. His leadership could appeal to centrists and moderate Liberals, though his lack of political experience remains a potential challenge.

The Conservative Surge and Poilievre’s Populism

Pierre Poilievre, the Conservative leader, has gained momentum, capitalizing on public discontent with the Liberal government. His populist approach—focused on economic freedom, reducing inflation, and making housing more affordable—resonates with many voters seeking change. While his policies have been criticized as overly simplistic, his rise signals a shift in public sentiment.

Key Issues in the Next Election

The upcoming federal election will be a pivotal moment for Canada. Key issues shaping the political landscape include:

• Economic Recovery: Canadians will demand concrete plans to address inflation, cost-of-living concerns, and job growth.
• Housing Affordability: Any successful party must offer viable solutions to improve access to affordable housing.
• Climate Policy: Balancing economic interests with environmental commitments will be a major challenge.
• Canada-U.S. Relations: Managing trade tensions with the U.S. under President Trump will require strategic diplomacy.

Conclusion: A New Chapter for Canada

Justin Trudeau’s tenure began with immense promise but ended in controversy and disillusionment. While he achieved notable progress in areas such as LGBTQ+ rights, gender equality, and pandemic response, his economic mismanagement, ethical lapses, and political miscalculations ultimately led to his downfall.

As Canada enters a new political era, the Liberal Party faces the challenge of redefining itself and regaining public trust. Whether the country embraces Poilievre’s conservative vision, a centrist alternative, or a renewed Liberal agenda, the coming months will shape the nation’s future for years to come.

One thing is certain: the Trudeau era has ended, but its impact on Canadian politics will be felt for a long time.

Bottom of Form